Carol Nicklaus, born August 22, 1939, in Wisconsin, died on October 21, 2026, leaving behind a life marked by devotion, warmth, and a deep love for her family. She will be remembered as a loving wife, mother, grandmother, great-grandmother, sister, and friend whose presence brought comfort and joy to those around her.
Carol married James Nicklaus on April 11, 1959, and together they built a life centered on family, faith, and togetherness. Through the years, she remained a steady and caring presence, always placing her loved ones at the center of her world. Her family remembers her as someone who gave generously of her time, her attention, and her heart.
She is survived by her husband, James, her daughters, Kay Holder and Kelly (Thomas)Baeten, her brother, Thomas (Linda)Sherwood, and her sister, Barb Holmes. She also leaves behind her grandchildren, Tracy Zeske, Adam Gagnon, Jimmy Holder, and Brian Baeten, along with her great-grandchildren, Nova, Lennon, Cash, Macy, Nolan, Logan, Cadence, Grayson, and Paisley. And several nieces and nephews. To them, she was more than a beloved relative. She was the heart of the family, and her grandchildren and great-grandchildren were everything to her.
Carol’s life was also shaped by the family members who went before her. She was preceded in death by her parents, Marvin and Margaret Sherwood, and by her brothers, Francis, Warren, Myron, and Gary. She was also preceded in death by three grandchildren, Brandon Sheldon, Clutch Zeske, and Victoria “Tori” Holder. Their memories remained close to her heart throughout her life, and now they are reunited.
Those who knew Carol will remember her for her loving nature and the simple joys that brought her happiness. She loved reading, playing cards, and cheering on her favorite teams, the Packers, Brewers, and Badgers. Whether she was spending time with family, enjoying a good book, or following a game, she found meaning in the moments that brought people together.
Carol’s legacy lives on in the family she cherished and in the many lives she touched with her gentle spirit. She will be remembered not only for the years she lived, but for the love she gave so freely and the lasting example she set. Her family and friends will hold close the memories of her laughter, her strength, and the unwavering love that defined her life.
Visitation for Carol will take place on Saturday Oct 31, 2026 from 10AM until 11AM at the Berth and Rosenthal Funeral Home. Funeral Services will follow at 11AM. Pastor Nathan Reed will be officiating.
