Monday, November 16, 2026
50 °
Clear
Log in Subscribe

Fraud Defense panel experts say teamwork is key to fighting fraud

Posted

MARINETTE – As the tinted window rolled down, the man placed the gold bars in the back seat. Then, the car drove away. What do you think happened next?

“The victim repeated the same process again, again and again, ultimately losing over half a million dollars,” said Jeremiah Gustafson of the Wisconsin Department of Justice.

More than 110 attendees heard firsthand stories like this at the Fraud Defense: True Stories. Real Scams. event on Tuesday, Oct. 27, at the Bayshore Arts Center.

What started with clicking the wrong link in an email led to the victim handing over gold bars in a Kohl’s parking lot in Neenah.

“Only together as a team can we really fight this,” Gustafson said.

The Stephenson National Bank & Trust, Peshtigo National Bank and Integra First Federal Credit Union hosted the event, emceed by longtime Wisconsin broadcaster Erin Davisson, in partnership with the Marinette County Sheriff’s Office and the Menominee, Marinette and Peshtigo police departments.

Gustafson encouraged all attendees to spread the information to family and friends, too.
“Scammers are very, very good at putting you in an emotional state of panic and fear,” Gustafson said.

The key is to stop and think. If it’s too good to be true, it usually is.

Greg Salmen, president of The Stephenson National Bank & Trust, opened the event with a simple question.

“If someone called you and told you they were your bank, would you believe them?” he said.
Most shook their heads no. However, a lot of audience members raised their hands later when someone asked if they kept their passwords in a notebook — a habit that could leave someone vulnerable if they lost that notebook or if that property was stolen.

Attendees learned powerful ways to protect themselves, including a recommendation from Gustafson for an online password manager. He recommended the online service Keeper and mentioned that a spouse should have access to that password. He also mentioned a few other technological tips:

  • Never, under any circumstances, allow someone remote access to your computer.
  • Check the domain — the word after the “@” symbol — of the email address. This will help you sort your email for scams.
  • A secure website starts with “https,” and will also have a padlock on the left hand side of the web address.

Speakers answered questions as the event continued. One couple said it was their third year attending, and they plan to be back because the information was so good.

What should you do if you’ve been scammed?

“The first 24 hours are absolutely critical,” said Tifanie Tremble, chief deposit officer and director of treasury management at The Stephenson National Bank & Trust. “The faster you act, the better the chance of reducing any potential loss.”

She said to call the bank immediately and change passwords on any email, online banking and any other compromised accounts. Other steps include enabling multi-factor authentication and contacting your credit bureau to potentially freeze your credit.

How are scammers using AI to trick people?

Andrew Bunch, a Menominee Police Officer, said AI is so advanced that people should expect calls, FaceTimes and photos impersonating a loved one. He said the AI landscape has advanced significantly in the past two years.

“There’s not a lot of things AI can’t do,” he said.

What are some common mistakes victims make?

“They keep it a secret,” said Jamie Nystrom, chief operations officer at Peshtigo National Bank.

“They’re too embarrassed to tell other people. So, talk about it.”

Wisconsin Department of Justice, Jeremiah Gustafson, Fraud Defense: True Stories. Real Scams., local news

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here